FBI evidence in Nancy Guthrie case draws two-suspect claims, retired agent weighs in

A increasing online firestorm is adding a caller twist to the alleged abduction of Nancy Guthrie. After the FBI released photos and surveillance video tied to her disappearance, galore are present pointing retired what they spot arsenic a troubling discrepancy — asking whether the images and video really amusement the aforesaid person. 

The questions are fueling speculation and putting a spotlight connected however national investigators vet captious grounds successful a high-profile case.

Retired Supervisory Special Agent of the FBI Scott Duffy told Fox News Digital that, astatine slightest from his archetypal review, the images look consistent.

"Right disconnected the bat, they bash look similar the aforesaid person," Duffy said. "I would beryllium hard pressed to spot 2 antithetic individuals."

WHAT THE TIMING OF THE FBI’S IMAGE RELEASE SUGGESTS IN THE NANCY GUTHRIE CASE: CRIME INSIDER

This representation released by the FBI shows an equipped idiosyncratic who appears to person a airy emitting from his rima astatine Nancy Guthrie's beforehand doorway the greeting of her disappearance successful Tucson, Arizona, connected Sunday, Feb. 1, 2026. (Provided by FBI)

Still, Duffy acknowledged that portion the idiosyncratic captured connected camera whitethorn beryllium the aforesaid idiosyncratic crossed the released materials, that does not regularisation retired the anticipation that much than 1 idiosyncratic could beryllium progressive successful the transgression itself. 

"I’ve got to judge much than 1 idiosyncratic did this — but you ne'er know," helium added, noting the lawsuit presents "so galore anomalies."

Duffy said investigators would person cautiously vetted the images earlier releasing them publically and are apt combing done each disposable item — from footwear and outerwear to imaginable logos and marque identifiers.

NANCY GUTHRIE WAS EXPECTED AT FRIEND’S HOME, NOT CHURCH ON DAY SHE VANISHED: SOURCE

This representation released by the FBI shows an equipped idiosyncratic appearing to person tampered with the camera astatine Nancy Guthrie's beforehand doorway the greeting of her disappearance successful Tucson, Arizona, connected Sunday, Feb. 1, 2026. (Provided by FBI)

"They privation to enactment a sanction marque connected 1 of those items," helium explained, describing however agents effort to place circumstantial covering manufacturers oregon markings that could constrictive the fishy pool. 

However, helium cautioned that mass-produced items tin bounds the usefulness of that strategy. "You recognize present millions oregon thousands of that person been generated and there’s nary mode to hint it to a peculiar store."

As for claims that advances successful facial designation oregon different biometric bundle could rapidly resoluteness questions astir the suspect’s identity, Duffy urged caution.

NANCY GUTHRIE'S ALLEGED BITCOIN RANSOM COULD BE PAID IN MINUTES AS MONDAY DEADLINE APPROACHES: EXPERT

"With each the covering helium has on, instrumentality enforcement has their enactment chopped retired for them," helium said. "I don’t deliberation immoderate bundle unsocial is going to beryllium capable to say, ‘Oh, that’s him.’"

Instead, Duffy suggested the footage whitethorn yet beryllium much invaluable erstwhile investigators make a circumstantial suspect. At that point, experts tin comparison surveillance video from aggregate locations, analyse gait and carnal build, and furniture successful integer grounds specified arsenic cellphone information to find whether idiosyncratic was adjacent Guthrie’s location astatine the clip of the alleged abduction.

Beyond whether the images picture the aforesaid person, Duffy said the suspect’s demeanor was different item that stood out.

FORMER FBI AGENT 'STUNNED' BY UNFORGIVING CONDITIONS COMPLICATING NANCY GUTHRIE SEARCH

"This idiosyncratic does not look to person immoderate consciousness of urgency," helium said, noting the idiosyncratic appeared calm and deliberate portion connected camera. "It seemed similar they had a occupation to bash and felt precise comfy successful doing it."

That deficiency of urgency, helium said, could suggest the fishy did not fearfulness contiguous detection and whitethorn person been acquainted with the spot oregon assured that nary 1 would interrupt.

Duffy besides addressed increasing online speculation surrounding gloves seen successful the footage and reports of discarded gloves recovered nearby. He explained that some suspects and investigators commonly deterioration latex gloves astatine scenes — suspects to debar leaving forensic evidence, and agents to debar contaminating it.

FIVE CRITICAL CLUES IN FBI FOOTAGE COULD PINPOINT SUSPECT IN NANCY GUTHRIE DISAPPEARANCE: EXPERTS

This representation released by the FBI shows an equipped idiosyncratic appearing to person tampered with the camera astatine Nancy Guthrie's beforehand doorway the greeting of her disappearance successful Tucson, Arizona, connected Sunday, Feb. 1, 2026. (Provided by FBI)

"This idiosyncratic has gone done large lengths to screen their individuality successful galore regards," Duffy said, adding that wearing latex gloves implicit different brace could bespeak an effort to forestall fibre transportation oregon tegument contact. At the aforesaid time, helium cautioned that discarded gloves unsocial are not definitive impervious of anything, arsenic instrumentality enforcement and exigency unit besides routinely deterioration and discard gloves during investigations.

While nationalist statement continues online, Duffy said investigators are apt relying connected a operation of forensic review, integer investigation and tips from the community.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

"Just springiness a sanction to instrumentality enforcement and fto them tally it down," helium said, explaining that adjacent partial tips tin pb to deeper analysis, including cellphone determination information and further surveillance comparisons.

As speculation swirls, Duffy emphasized that high-profile investigations are methodical and layered — adjacent if answers are not instantly disposable to the public.

Stepheny Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and migrant crime. Send communicative tips to [email protected].